Thu 24 Jun 2010
Antigone and I
Posted by Charlotte under A Literary Education
[6] Comments
Antigone is one of these plays with which I feel I have a very intimate relationship, even though I never read the Sophocles’ version. My introduction to Antigone was made through Anouilh, back when I was a 15 year-old student in France. The class was taught by a young professor, whose name I can’t remember right now, but whose face has stayed with me — a very rare occurrence. Mademoiselle… Anyway. I fell in love with the play, fell in love very hard, and read so much Anouilh that year. There are to this day moments when my life goes Anouilh-colored. Being lost in a vast crowd, feeling tiny and defiant and free, is an Anouilh moment for me. I feel like he’s writing me. It’s a little scary and very wonderful, this sensation that being lost and drifting is exactly where I’m supposed to be, my rightful place in the world — at least for the time being.
It is not Antigone, though, who captured my imagination back then, but Ismene. It might have been because I ended up reading her lines so often in class that I identified with her, but I rather think that it was something more. When I started reading her, she allowed me to express a part of my identity that needed to be spoken. It felt vital, necessary and freeing simultaneously. All I know is that I remember these hours in the classroom like no others. Another girl was almost always Antigone. Perhaps she too found something then; it is quite remarkable that the teacher would have let the two of us take over the play the way we did. Then again, this woman was quite a remarkable teacher.
What distinguished Ismene from Antigone for me was not willingness to compromise with Créon (power, politics, you name it) but the understanding of small things. Flamboyance for Antigone, empathy for Ismene; the two opposed like I had never known they did, and that rang true. Antigone claims to love life more passionately than Ismene, and much as my love for the latter would have made me want to pretend her claim was contradicted by her acts, I believed her. However her passion blinds her to humble things, to contradictions; her passion makes it unacceptable for her to just.. float She has to act. She stands for something that can win or be defeated, which I felt made her more contingent.
As part of my “summer of reading things that have been sitting around for too long”, I started reading Antigone’s claim by Judith Butler. It is a series of lectures that were given to undergrads and grads, and are collected and published by Columbia University press. I will also be reading Sophocles’ Antigone, and probably re-read Anouilh’s after that. Right now however, I am struggling through Antigone’s claim, which is still way beyond my critical abilities, fishing for what I can take out of it. It is very fascinating and a good exercise in stretching out my intellectual muscles. Hopefully that will serve me next year — I just found out I have passed all my exams and am the happy recipient of a licence de lettres modernes, a BA. I am definitely registering for the master LGC (Master’s in General and Comparative Literature) — my plan is to get one year under my belt simultaneously to applying to grad programs in the US, and maybe in Europe as well.
I have nothing interesting to say about your post, just glad you’re posting again!
I’ll have a look for Anouilh’s Antigone.
And félicitations on your degree!
Merci !
I’d be curious to hear what you think about Anouilh — I read it a long time ago… I’m kind of scared to reopen his plays and be disappointed now !
I read Sophocles’ Antigone last year and liked it but liked Aeschylus’ version in Libation Bearers better. Your view of Antigone and Ismene is interesting. In Sophocles’ version I have a hard time with both of them, Antigone is too over the top and focused on revenge and Ismene is too willing to capitulate. Looking forward to your new readings of the play.
Congratulations on your B.A.! And good luck on the grad school plans!
Stefanie, Aeschylus is definitely a favorite of mine — but I am confused (bear with me), as the only Libation Bearers I know is the Oresteia’s… Where you thinking of Seven against Thebes (which — good point — I should definitely read!), maybe it’s in the same book for you? Or am I missing something?
You aren’t confused I’m confused. I was thinking of Elektra, doh! Sophocles’ Antigone is very good. I didn’t much like Seven Against Thebes the description of each of the “Seven” got a big long but the drama between the brothers is really interesting.
Oh, I see! I read Elektra last year and really loved it. And amusingly, I also noticed some almost identical interpretation of the Oresteia and of the Antigone myth in terms of a transition from a feminine/ family centered system to a male/ justice controled one. I’ll try to talk more about this soon.